As a plan sponsor of a self-insured health plan, it’s crucial to maintain accurate records and ensure that all enrolled employees meet the eligibility criteria. However, situations can arise where outdated information leads to ineligible employees being enrolled in the health plan. If you’ve discovered that employees working 25 hours per week have been enrolled based on old handbook information, while your plan documents and Summary Plan Description (SPD) correctly state a 30-hour threshold, swift and strategic action is required.
Immediate Steps for Plan Sponsors
Upon discovering such errors, you must act promptly to minimize complications and potential liabilities. Here are two primary options to consider:
Allow Ineligible Employees to Remain Enrolled:
- Fairness Consideration: Allowing employees to remain in the plan for the rest of the plan year can be seen as fair, especially if they relied on the outdated handbook information. This approach reduces the risk of employees seeking equitable relief due to miscommunication.
- Stop-Loss Insurance Risk: Check with your stop-loss insurer before proceeding. Stop-loss coverage typically adheres to the terms in the plan document, not ancillary documents like handbooks. Without insurer approval, claims from these employees might not be covered under your stop-loss policy.
Remove Ineligible Employees from the Plan:
- Consistency with Plan Terms: Removing these employees aligns with the plan document and SPD, mitigating the risk of significant uncovered claims under your stop-loss policy.
- Prospective Removal: Ensure the removal is prospective, not retroactive, to avoid the impermissible “rescission” of coverage. Retroactive removal could lead to significant legal and ethical issues.
- Equitable Relief Risk: Be aware of the potential for employees to claim equitable relief for lost benefits due to reliance on the outdated handbook.
Ensuring Compliance and Fair Treatment
Consistency is key in handling such situations. Treat all similarly situated employees alike to avoid claims of discrimination under various laws. Disparate treatment can lead to claims of discrimination based on sex, race, age, or health status. Additionally, adhere to the nondiscrimination rules under Code § 105(h) for self-insured health plans.
Discovering ineligible employees enrolled in your health plan requires careful consideration and prompt action. Whether you decide to keep the employees enrolled for the remainder of the plan year or remove them, ensure that your actions are consistent with plan terms and fair to all employees. By addressing the issue swiftly and consulting with your stop-loss insurer, you can mitigate potential risks and maintain the integrity of your health plan.
Source: Thomson Reuters
